Should You Buy Or Rent A Home? This Secret Will Help You Decide

The buy versus rent debate is currently a hot topic when it comes to housing and personal finance.

Personally, I think too many people get too caught up in the numbers.

Yes, numbers are important, but there is something even more important. Buying or renting a home is a lifestyle choice in addition to a financial choice.

You shouldn’t make your decision on only one of these factors.

You must consider both.

Financial Decisions

Renting and buying a home are two totally different beasts when it comes to money. Renting offers a fair amount of financial certainty for your housing expenses.

You will know exactly how much your rent will be for the period of your lease. You won’t likely have to pay much else for your basic housing costs.

When you buy a home, your mortgage payment will stay close to the same if you have a fixed rate mortgage. Of course, it may increase or decrease based on changing real estate taxes and insurance rates.

Additionally, if you have a variable rate mortgage, the payment can change as interest rates change.

Utility expenses are another large cost that are associated with your housing. If you rent, you might luck out and have some of your utilities included in your rent. However, if you buy a home, you’re stuck with all of the utility bills in most cases.

The benefit of owning a home is the fact that you can make your home more efficient with regards to heating, cooling, electricity and water usage if it is a smart financial move.

As a renter, it wouldn’t make sense to make these improvements as they’d likely be cost prohibitive. They wouldn’t pay off before you had to move again.

Yard maintenance is sometimes covered in your rent as a renter and could potentially be included in homeowners association fees if you own a home.

However, this particular cost will vary widely depending on your specific situation regardless of whether you’re a renter or you buy your home.

Regular home maintenance is almost always paid for by your landlord if you’re renting. If you own your home, you need to make sure you can afford all of the maintenance that is necessary or your home could end up losing value quickly.

Once you take all of these factors into consideration, you should have a good idea if buying or renting will be cheaper on a monthly basis. If buying ends up cheaper, remember that you’ll have to include money for a down payment and closing costs as well.

Even with all of these financial considerations, you still need to consider the lifestyle choice you’d be making when you choose if you’ll rent or if you’ll buy a home.

Lifestyle Decisions

Unfortunately, the better financial decision doesn’t always make sense when you consider your lifestyle.

The secret that will help you make a sound decision about whether to buy or rent is matching your finances with your lifestyle. Owning and renting a home are two very different lifestyle decisions.

If your lifestyle doesn’t fit your choice, you could end up in a world of hurt, financially speaking.

The first lifestyle choice is the length of time you’ll live in a home. If you’re not sure where you’ll be in one year, let alone five years from now, then you’re most likely better off renting a home.

You can sign short leases and minimize the financial impact a mobile lifestyle would have on your wallet.

However, if you’re certain you’ll be in a particular area for decades, you might want to put down roots and avoid the costs of rent increases. After all, moving every couple of years sucks when your landlord doesn’t want to renew your lease.

If you hate yard work and performing maintenance tasks around the house, renting will definitely fit your lifestyle better. Since these things aren’t normally the responsibility of the renter, you’ll alleviate that stress on your life.

If you live for having the perfect yard, you probably would want to own the home so you don’t spend a ton of money fixing up a yard before the landlord decides not to renew your lease.

As you can see, deciding whether to own or rent a home isn’t a simple decision. It takes a lot of reflection on your situation to determine what is best for you. Don’t let others bully you into a situation you aren’t comfortable with. Do what’s best for you!

What do you think about the buy vs rent debate? Which side to you fall on, or do you run the numbers for every scenario?

Like What You See?

Join the other readers who have signed up for our email newsletter! No spam, just periodic updates to help improve your finances!

About Lance Cothern

Lance Cothern, a Certified Public Accountant (CPA) licensed in the Commonwealth of Virginia, is the founder of Money Manifesto. You can read more about him here or connect with him on Facebook, Twitter, Google+ or Pinterest.


  1. Brodie Hock says:

    When in doubt…!

  2. Thank you for this — I feel like personal finance bloggers can focus solely on the money issue. But, we make a lot of decisions without finances being the #1 priority, and that’s OK. I mean, who regrets having their child? Definitely not the best financial decision 😛

    We are in a not-so-good financial position, with almost $200,000 in student loans, but we are in the home-buying market. We would like to live closer to my parents and in a great school district, and where we want to live just doesn’t have a robust rental market. So, we’re looking to buy something modest.

    • Sounds like Obama loan forgiveness would be a good idea for you! Research loan consolidation and then “pay-as-you-earn” option. After 20 years of low payments the rest of your debt will be forgiven. You’ll have to see if this makes sense for you to do, but good luck! Living in debt is never fun.

  3. Most homeowners think that when they sell their home, they need to immediately buy a new home. Because of this they may rush to find a home that may not be their perfect home. Sometimes it is better to rent for a few months and take time to find that “just right” home.

  4. Buy. At least in my country rent and mortgage are almost similar, so, after 10-30 years I’d rather have ‘something’ than just pay rent. We do have a daughter, so we think of making it easier to her

  5. Definitely agree with you on this. Finances are certainly a big consideration, but everyone’s situation is different. If you want to live in a particular neighborhood one choice make more sense than the other. For example an area with an excellent school system but home prices are high. That’s just one thing I can think of off the top of my head. We don’ t have any children so not a consideration for us. Mobility might be another, an area has good public transportation system and being “green” is high on your priority list. Like I said a lot of different things to be considered.

  6. I think one of the most important things to consider when weighing buying vs renting is where your finances will be in the next 5-10 years. Is your income stable or increasing? Are you happy with your current job/career? The last thing you want to do is get yourself tied up into mortgage payments and two years later want to quit your job but have to stick with it because you can’t afford to take a risk of leaving.

    • Definitely, but at the same time you can’t count on an increasing income to afford the mortgage payment in my opinion. You have to be able to afford it when you buy, too.

Share Your Thoughts